Clinical bottom line
Both laparoscopic Heller myotomy (LHM) and peroral endoscopic myotomy (POEM) are effective and safe interventions for achalasia, with comparable symptom relief and functional outcomes. POEM offers a less invasive approach with shorter hospital stays and faster recovery but may be associated with a higher incidence of postoperative gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). LHM, often combined with a partial fundoplication, remains the standard surgical treatment, particularly in pediatric populations and patients at higher risk of reflux. Current evidence supports individualized treatment selection based on patient factors, achalasia subtype, and institutional expertise (Patti et al., 2024; Dimopoulou et al., 2024; Niazi et al., 2025).
What the evidence shows
Patti et al. (2024) provide a contemporary review highlighting that both LHM and POEM achieve high rates of symptomatic improvement measured by Eckardt scores, with success rates exceeding 85% at mid-term follow-up. POEM’s endoscopic approach avoids external incisions and allows tailored myotomy length, which may benefit type III achalasia.
Dimopoulou et al. (2024) conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis focusing on pediatric patients, finding that while both procedures are effective, LHM with fundoplication is preferred due to better reflux control and long-term safety data in children.
Niazi et al. (2025) summarize recent literature underscoring that POEM is associated with shorter operative times and hospital stays but a higher risk of postoperative GERD compared to LHM with fundoplication. Both procedures have low complication rates.
Sobral et al. (2024) meta-analyzed outcomes and confirmed that fundoplication during LHM reduces reflux incidence, a benefit not routinely achieved with POEM, which lacks an anti-reflux procedure.
Older landmark studies such as Schlottmann et al. (2018) and Olson et al. (2019) corroborate these findings, establishing the efficacy and safety profiles of both techniques.
Caveats and uncertainty
Long-term comparative data beyond 5 years remain limited, especially for POEM.
Variability in reflux assessment methods complicates interpretation of GERD incidence.
Operator experience significantly influences outcomes, particularly for POEM.
Optimal patient selection criteria for each procedure are not fully standardized.
Limited data exist on outcomes in complex or recurrent achalasia cases.
How this may change practice
Clinicians should consider POEM as a minimally invasive alternative to LHM in adult patients, especially those with type III achalasia or contraindications to surgery.
LHM with fundoplication remains preferred in pediatric patients and those at high risk for reflux.
Preoperative counseling should include discussion of reflux risk and need for long-term acid suppression after POEM.
Multidisciplinary teams and centers with expertise in both techniques can tailor treatment to individual patient profiles.
Future research should focus on long-term comparative effectiveness and reflux mitigation strategies post-POEM.