Clinical bottom line
Current evidence supports both laparoscopic and open repair as effective surgical options for inguinal hernia, with choice guided by patient factors, surgeon expertise, and resource availability. Laparoscopic repair offers advantages including reduced postoperative pain, faster return to normal activities, and lower wound complication rates, particularly in bilateral or recurrent hernias. However, open repair remains a reliable and cost-effective approach, especially for unilateral primary hernias and in settings with limited laparoscopic resources. International guidelines recommend individualized decision-making incorporating patient preference and clinical context (HerniaSurge Group, 2018; Kwon et al., 2017).
What the evidence shows
The HerniaSurge Group (2018) provides comprehensive international guidelines endorsing laparoscopic repair techniques—totally extraperitoneal (TEP) and transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP)—for bilateral and recurrent inguinal hernias, citing lower chronic pain incidence and quicker recovery compared to open mesh repair.
Kwon et al. (2017) review comparative outcomes, reporting that laparoscopic repair is associated with less postoperative pain and earlier return to work, though operative times may be longer and costs higher. They emphasize that open repair remains effective with low recurrence rates when performed by experienced surgeons.
Natchiar et al. (2015) present a comparative analysis demonstrating similar recurrence rates between open and laparoscopic repair for unilateral hernias, but highlight reduced postoperative discomfort and shorter hospital stays with laparoscopy.
Gould et al. (2008) discuss that laparoscopic approaches require advanced surgical skills and have a learning curve, which may influence complication rates and outcomes.
Kler et al. (2021) focus on sportsman’s hernia, a related groin pathology, finding that laparoscopic TEP and TAPP repairs yield comparable outcomes, suggesting laparoscopic techniques’ versatility in groin pain syndromes.
Caveats and uncertainty
Laparoscopic repair demands specialized training and equipment, limiting availability in some centers.
Long-term data comparing chronic pain and recurrence beyond five years remain limited.
Patient factors such as obesity, prior lower abdominal surgery, and comorbidities may influence approach selection.
Cost-effectiveness analyses vary by healthcare system and resource setting.
Surgeon preference and experience significantly impact outcomes.
How this may change practice
Surgeons should tailor inguinal hernia repair approach based on hernia characteristics, patient comorbidities, and available expertise.
Laparoscopic repair should be considered first-line for bilateral and recurrent hernias when feasible.
Open repair remains appropriate for primary unilateral hernias, especially in resource-limited settings.
Enhanced training in laparoscopic techniques may expand access and improve outcomes.
Shared decision-making with patients regarding risks, benefits, and recovery expectations is essential.