Clinical bottom line
Surgical repair remains the definitive treatment for complete (full-thickness) rectal prolapse in adults. Current evidence from a comprehensive Cochrane systematic review indicates that both laparoscopic and open surgical approaches achieve similar long-term outcomes in terms of recurrence and symptom relief. Laparoscopic surgery may offer advantages in reduced postoperative pain and shorter hospital stay, but evidence is limited by small sample sizes and heterogeneity. Choice of approach should be individualized based on patient factors, surgeon expertise, and resource availability (Tou et al., 2015).
What the evidence shows
Tou et al. (2015) conducted a Cochrane systematic review evaluating surgical interventions for full-thickness rectal prolapse, including comparisons of laparoscopic versus open abdominal approaches. The review included randomized controlled trials and observational studies, though the number of high-quality RCTs was limited.
The evidence suggests no significant difference in recurrence rates between laparoscopic and open abdominal repairs. Both approaches effectively reduce prolapse and improve continence and quality of life.
Laparoscopic surgery was associated with reduced postoperative pain and shorter hospital length of stay in some studies, reflecting minimally invasive benefits.
Operative times were generally longer with laparoscopy, but this did not translate into increased morbidity.
Data on long-term functional outcomes and complications were insufficient to definitively favor one approach.
Caveats and uncertainty
The overall quality of evidence is low to moderate due to small sample sizes, study heterogeneity, and risk of bias.
Variability in surgical techniques (e.g., rectopexy type, mesh use) complicates comparisons.
Long-term follow-up data are limited, restricting assessment of durability and late complications.
Patient selection bias and surgeon experience may influence outcomes but were inconsistently reported.
No consensus exists on the optimal surgical approach for specific patient subgroups, such as elderly or frail individuals.
How this may change practice
Surgeons should consider laparoscopic repair as a viable alternative to open surgery for rectal prolapse, particularly when minimally invasive expertise and resources are available.
Patient comorbidities, anatomy, and preferences should guide individualized surgical planning.
Enhanced recovery protocols may be more readily implemented with laparoscopic approaches due to reduced pain and faster mobilization.
Further high-quality randomized trials with standardized techniques and longer follow-up are needed to refine recommendations.
Multidisciplinary discussion and shared decision-making remain essential in managing rectal prolapse.