Clinical bottom line
Current evidence on the surgical management of gastroduodenal perforations suggests that primary repair remains the preferred initial approach in most cases, particularly for small, contained perforations without extensive tissue necrosis or contamination. Resection with anastomosis may be reserved for larger, complicated perforations or those associated with significant tissue loss or ischemia. The choice between primary repair and resection strategies should be individualized based on intraoperative findings, patient stability, and perforation characteristics. However, direct comparative data specifically focused on gastroduodenal perforations remain limited, and much of the current guidance is extrapolated from related gastrointestinal perforation studies.
What the evidence shows
The surgical management of gastroduodenal perforations traditionally involves primary repair, often with an omental patch, aiming to close the defect and control contamination. This approach is supported by longstanding surgical principles and remains the mainstay for small perforations with viable surrounding tissue (Barnes et al., 1984). Primary repair is generally associated with shorter operative times, reduced morbidity, and faster recovery compared to more extensive resections.
Comparative studies in related gastrointestinal perforations provide insight into outcomes of primary repair versus resection. For example, Dr. Shivaprasad et al. (2020) and Panda Charan et al. (2017) analyzed jejunoileal perforations and found that primary repair was associated with favorable outcomes compared to resection and anastomosis, including lower complication rates and shorter hospital stays. Although these studies focus on small bowel perforations, the principles may be cautiously extrapolated to gastroduodenal perforations given similar pathophysiology.
Fitzgerald et al. (2024) evaluated colon injuries and reported that for American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) grade I and II injuries, primary repair was not inferior to resection in terms of morbidity and mortality. This supports a conservative surgical approach when tissue viability permits.
In the context of drug-induced gastroduodenal perforations, Garner et al. (2002) highlighted that early surgical intervention with primary repair yielded acceptable outcomes, emphasizing the importance of timely management.
Gunadi et al. (2026) provided a recent comprehensive review of gastroduodenal perforations, underscoring that while primary repair is standard, resection may be necessary in cases of large perforations, necrotic tissue, or malignancy. They also noted that patient factors such as hemodynamic stability and comorbidities influence surgical decision-making.
Caveats and uncertainty
Direct, high-quality randomized controlled trials comparing primary repair versus resection specifically for gastroduodenal perforations are lacking. Most available evidence is observational or extrapolated from studies on other gastrointestinal perforations, which may differ in anatomy, microbial flora, and healing capacity.
Heterogeneity in perforation size, etiology (e.g., peptic ulcer disease, malignancy, trauma), timing of presentation, and patient comorbidities complicates the generalizability of findings. For example, drug-induced perforations may behave differently than those caused by chronic ulceration or malignancy.
Older surgical texts such as Barnes et al. (1984) remain authoritative for foundational techniques but do not reflect advances in perioperative care, minimally invasive surgery, or adjunctive therapies.
The role of adjuncts like collagen patches or biologic plugs, studied in other perforation contexts (Nachiyar Rajeshwari et al., 2025), has not been well evaluated in gastroduodenal perforations.
How this may change practice
Surgeons should continue to prioritize primary repair for gastroduodenal perforations when feasible, given its association with favorable outcomes and lower morbidity. Careful intraoperative assessment of tissue viability and contamination is critical to identify cases where resection may be warranted.
Increased awareness of patient-specific factors and perforation characteristics can guide tailored surgical strategies rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. Surgeons should remain vigilant for indications of resection, such as large or malignant perforations, or when primary repair is unlikely to succeed.
Future research focusing specifically on gastroduodenal perforations, including prospective comparative studies and incorporation of minimally invasive techniques, may refine surgical decision-making and optimize outcomes.