Clinical bottom line
Virtual reality (VR) simulation is an increasingly validated tool for surgical skill training in orthopedics, particularly in knee arthroplasty and arthroscopy. Evidence supports VR’s ability to improve technical proficiency, enhance spatial awareness, and accelerate learning curves among trainees. However, variability in simulation fidelity, transferability to the operating room, and integration into curricula remain challenges. VR should be considered a complementary adjunct to traditional training, with ongoing refinement and validation needed to optimize its educational impact (Goh et al., 2021; Mao et al., 2021; Kayaalp et al., 2025).
What the evidence shows
Goh et al. (2021) systematically reviewed VR and augmented reality (AR) applications in knee arthroplasty training, finding that VR simulation improves surgical accuracy and reduces errors in novice surgeons. They highlight enhanced engagement and the ability to practice rare or complex scenarios safely.
Mao et al. (2021) conducted a systematic review demonstrating that immersive VR training leads to significant improvements in surgical skills, including instrument handling and procedural knowledge, with some evidence of skill transfer to real surgeries.
Kayaalp et al. (2025) discuss the expanding role of the metaverse—integrating VR, AR, and mixed reality—in orthopedic education, emphasizing its potential to revolutionize training, preoperative planning, and rehabilitation through immersive, interactive environments.
Cate et al. (2023) note that while VR simulation is widely adopted, there is a need to shift focus toward competency-based curricula and objective assessment metrics to maximize educational outcomes.
Feeley et al. (2021) review predictive validity of VR simulators, concluding that higher-fidelity systems better predict operative performance, supporting their inclusion in surgical training programs.
Caveats and uncertainty
Most studies focus on short-term skill acquisition with limited data on long-term retention and clinical outcomes.
Heterogeneity in VR platforms, scenarios, and assessment tools complicates cross-study comparisons.
Cost and accessibility of high-fidelity VR systems may limit widespread adoption, especially in resource-constrained settings.
Evidence for transferability to complex orthopedic procedures beyond arthroplasty and arthroscopy is limited.
Standardized guidelines for integrating VR into orthopedic training curricula are lacking.
How this may change practice
Orthopedic training programs can incorporate VR simulation to supplement hands-on experience, particularly for early learners and complex procedures.
Objective performance metrics from VR platforms may facilitate competency-based progression and targeted remediation.
Use of VR may reduce patient risk by allowing trainees to refine skills before live surgery.
Integration with augmented and mixed reality technologies could enhance preoperative planning and intraoperative guidance.
Future curricula should emphasize validated VR modules aligned with clinical competencies and incorporate longitudinal assessment.
Collaboration between educators, developers, and professional societies is needed to standardize VR training frameworks.